In alt.usage.english, on Sat, 31 Aug 2024 10:03:05 +1000, Peter Moylan
Post by Peter MoylanPost by Tony CooperDrifting a bit...we often see "made redundant" used in the UK to
mean a person is no longer employed by the organization. That
suggests to us that the person is no longer needed because the job no
longer needs doing, the organization is reducing their payroll, or
there are others who do the same job.
Yet, it seems to include being removed from the job for any
non-criminal reason. It seems that being incompetant is grounds for
being made redundant...a polite way of saying the person was sacked.
At least in Australia, there is a legal aspect to this. There are, or
were, unfair dismissal laws that meant you couldn't just sack someone on
a whim.
I'm not too informed about this but I think in the US some business with
union shops have this rule too.
Post by Peter MoylanThere had to be good grounds. One way around this was to declare
the position redundant.
And maybe this workaround.
Post by Peter MoylanI think that meant that the employer had to wait
a year before refilling the position, but a workaround was to create a
new position whose description was subtly different.
In the popular mind, then, redundancy was seen as a euphemism to
describe just about any way of getting rid of workers.
And maybe this result.
Post by Peter MoylanThese days the bigger companies have moved on to a different approach.
They don't have employees, they have contractors supplied by labour hire
firms. It's easier to sack a contractor, and you don't have to pay them
as well.
When I worked at Bethlehem Steel Corp, I was a contractor as a computer
programmer. I was there for years. I'm not sure why they used
contractors. They also had employees, some of whom (most of whom?) had
been mill employees who learned the new trade after they became
"redundant" in the mill because of mechanization. I don't want to call
it partial automation because things were still initiated manually. I
think the Continuous Caster made some jobs unnecessary. Or maybe it was
because one of the mills was closed entirely
Yes, no problem firing a contractor. Tell his boss and he's out by the
next morning, but I only know of one time they did that of our group of
about 20, and afaict, he fully deserved it. Wouldn't do what he was
told, wanted to do something else. Oh, yes, my own contracting company
fired me, but the client (Beth Steel) arranged for me to work for
another small contracting company before I even knew I'd been fired. I
think I was his only employee.
When I had a fight with my girlfriend (who also worked there for the
same contracting company, for longer, and had a higher job than I did),
I think I left early and after I got home the contracting company called
me and wanted me to come in and talk. I said I was already home and
didn't want to go out again, but I'd come in the next morning. He
repeated that I should come in now, and I refused. (It was silly. They
can yell at me tomorrow just as well, plus I was in a bad mood because
of the fight with the girlfriend and I would have been contentious with
them.)
I forget if I did go in the next morning But I know that the next
afternoon my client supervisor (that is , he worked for Beth Steel and
was in charge of the project we were working on) had me into his office
and was as nice as could be, more like a father than a boss, didn't
rebuke me at all, just talked about my problem. And not because it was
an effective management style but because that's the way he was. I
already felt more loyalty to the client (who was paying and deserved my
efforts) than I did to my actual employer, and this strengthened that
feeling a lot.
A year earlier, the contracting company was trying to decrease the
float, you might call it. Mostly they paid us out of the money that the
client paid them, but they had to keep some cash in the checking account
to pay when we werent' billable because we were on vacation. So they
told us we had to give 30 or maybe 60 days advance notice when we were
going to take a day off. I asked my on-site contractor-boss, What
happens if I suddently want to take a day off? He said, That's what
sick leave is for. No requirement to be sick, apparently.
The contracting company was in business for 47 years, with branches in
several or manny cities, and I read that they had over 10,000 employees,
but they were sold when the founder was 69yo and were named a few years
later. The founder, after whom it was named, had written a very
short book, which they gave to every employee, on one specific little
aspect of management. It said when a supervisor criticizes a
subordinate, he should start off with a minute of praise, 3 minutes of
criticism, and a minute of praise. But I had been criticized or rebuked
a couple times and no one ever did this.
--
Please say where you live, or what
area's English you are asking about.
So your question or answer makes sense.
. .
I have lived all my life in the USA,
Western Pa. Indianapolis, Chicago,
Brooklyn, Baltimore.